Nikon Z9 vs. Sony Alpha 1: Rolling Shutter Comparison. Picture: Family of Tech
Nikon Z9 vs. Sony Alpha 1: Rolling Shutter Comparison. Picture: Family of Tech

Nikon Z9 vs. Sony Alpha 1: Rolling Shutter Comparison

2022-01-03
2 mins read

One of the major tests reviewers are eager to perform regarding the new Nikon Z9, is the examination of its ability to produce almost zero rolling shutter artifacts when shooting videos. Therefore, the Z9 was compared to the very fast Sony Alph 1. Both of them present solid results in eliminating the skewed images when shooting fast-moving objects.

Nikon Z9: Rolling shutter test. Picture: Family of Tech
Nikon Z9: Rolling shutter test. Picture: Family of Tech

Nikon Z9: “World’s fastest scanning speed”

The recently announced Nikon Z9 is advertised as the “World’s fastest scanning speed” due to the newly developed sensor that is backup up by a powerful processor. As stated by Nikon: “Designed by Nikon specifically to bring ultra-high-resolution image quality to high-speed shooting applications. Achieves the world’s fastest scanning speed, 12x faster data readout than the acclaimed Z 7II, and absolutely spectacular image quality in stills and 8K videos”. Indeed, the Z9 is armed with an electronic shutter that “achieves the world’s most minimal rolling-shutter distortion” especially in still mode. However, what about videos?

Nikon Z9: Rolling shutter test. Picture: Matt Granger
Nikon Z9: Rolling shutter test. Picture: Matt Granger

Reduced rolling shutter artifacts on video capture

Nikon claims that the core of the Z9 is the newly developed FX-format 45.7MP BSI stacked CMOS sensor, and its stacked design offers fast readout speeds and helps to reduce rolling shutter. Reviewers also claim zero rolling shutter artifacts which are an essential factor to action sports cinematography. It’s obvious that in order to eliminate completely the skewing side effects, a global shutter sensor must be preferred. However, Nikon claims that the Z9 is almost like a global shutter in terms of performances of minimization of rolling shutter artifacts. Luckily, the video below shows that it’s almost true. The Nikon Z9 doesn’t allow a complete zero rolling shutter, but it’s close enough. Watch the part of the Rolling Shutter test is presented in the video below:

A comparison to the Alpha 1

When talking about a mirrorless that is familiar with its reduced rolling shutter artifacts, the Sony Alpha 1 is named immediately. In fact, the recent models of Alpha mirrorless shine because of their minimal rolling shutter artifacts. Hence, it’s very logical to compare the Alpha flagship (=1) to the Nikon Z9 when shooing 8K footage. Explore the video below that demonstrates this comparison by doing a couple of very simple tests:

Summary

The Nikon Z9 has a very fast readout. No doubt about that! However, it doesn’t own a ‘zero rolling shutter’. Thus, the skewed artifacts can be noticeable. The good news is that those artifacts are pretty minimal and can be barely noticed, even when shooting fast-moving objects The degree of the rolling shutter artifacts are very much similar to those of the Sony Alpha 1 and even might be a bit better. That’s a piece of good news for action sports shooters. Furthermore, it appears that reducing those artifacts is one of the main issues taken care of by manufacturers that develop video cameras for the pro-market.

Product List

Here’re the products mentioned in the article, and the links to purchase them from authorized dealers. 

Yossy is a filmmaker who specializes mainly in action sports cinematography. Yossy also lectures about the art of independent filmmaking in leading educational institutes, academic programs, and festivals, and his independent films have garnered international awards and recognition.
Yossy is the founder of Y.M.Cinema Magazine.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Get the best of filmmaking!

Subscribe to Y.M.Cinema Magazine to get the latest news and insights on cinematography and filmmaking!

Get the best of filmmaking!

Subscribe to Y.M.Cinema Magazine to get the latest news and insights on cinematography and filmmaking!

Watch: Short Film That Shows the Low-Light Capabilities of the Blackmagic Pocket 6K Pro
Previous Story

Watch: Short Film That Shows the Low-Light Capabilities of the Blackmagic Pocket 6K Pro

Shooting A Commercial in a (Real) Zero-Gravity Environment. Picture: AJ Bleyer
Next Story

Shooting A Commercial in a (Real) Zero-Gravity Environment (Parabolic Flight)

Latest from Compare

Cooke SP3 vs. Zeiss Nano Primes: Which is Better?

Cooke SP3 vs. Zeiss Nano Primes: Which is Better?

Yet another excellent educational video by CVP. This time, a straightforward comparison between two similar but very different lenses: The Cooke SP3 vs. Zeiss Nano Primes. Which is better? Explore below. High-end…
Go toTop

Don't Miss

Why Did Sony Use the Same Sensor in the Alpha 1 II?

Why Did Sony Use the Same Sensor in the Alpha 1 II?

Sony’s decision to reuse the 50.1MP sensor from the Alpha 1 in its successor, the Alpha 1 II, reflects a deliberate strategy. While…
Sony a1 II: A "Flagship" Without Direction for Videographers

Sony a1 II: A “Flagship” Without Direction for Videographers

Sony’s newly announced Alpha 1 II arrives with an unmistakable air of stagnation for the filmmaking community. Touted as a groundbreaking flagship, the…